Guitar Start Guide
Choosing between an acoustic vs electric guitar for beginners is the first real decision you’ll make, and it’s the one people agonise over most. Here’s the honest answer up front: both are excellent places to start, and the “wrong” choice is really just the guitar you don’t enjoy picking up. What matters far more is that the instrument suits the music you actually want to play and feels comfortable enough that you keep coming back to it.
Below we’ll walk through the real differences — cost, playability, sound, and practicality — without the forum arguments. By the end you’ll know which one fits your budget, your living situation, and your ears.
The short answer
Start on an acoustic if you mainly want to sing and strum, learn campfire songs, and keep things simple with no extra gear. Start on an electric if you’re drawn to rock, blues, metal, or pop, or if you find fat acoustic necks and stiff strings physically off-putting. Neither builds “better” fundamentals — chords, rhythm, and fretting hand technique transfer directly between the two.
Acoustic vs electric: the comparison table
| Feature | Acoustic | Electric |
|---|---|---|
| Starting cost | Guitar only — the cheaper way in | Guitar + amp + cable, so a higher total to get started |
| Playability | Thicker neck, higher string tension — harder on fingertips at first | Thinner neck, lighter strings, lower action — easier to fret |
| Volume control | Always audible; can’t turn it down | Use headphones through the amp for near-silent practice |
| Portability | Grab and go, no setup | Needs an amp and cable to sound its best |
| Best for | Singer-songwriter, folk, pop, worship, campfire | Rock, blues, metal, funk, lead playing |
| Maintenance | Simple; occasional string changes | More knobs, pickups and electronics to learn |
Cost: what you’ll really spend
An acoustic is cheaper to get started because there’s nothing to plug in — the box is the amplifier. A playable beginner acoustic is the single cheapest way to get started. An electric needs at least a small practice amp and a cable, so even though the guitar itself can be inexpensive, a sensible starter setup costs meaningfully more once you add those. The good news is that beginner electric bundles are genuinely useful, and a small 10–15 watt amp is all you need for years. For specific models we rate, see our best beginner guitars guide.
Check current prices on Amazon: Yamaha FG800 acoustic · Squier Sonic Stratocaster · Fender Frontman 10G amp →
Playability: which is easier on your hands?
This is where the electric quietly wins for a lot of beginners. Electrics have thinner strings, lower “action” (the gap between strings and fretboard), and slimmer necks, so pressing down chords takes less finger strength. Acoustics fight back a little harder at first — sore fingertips are normal for the first couple of weeks regardless, but they’re more pronounced on a steel-string acoustic.
That said, “harder” isn’t “bad.” Plenty of people start on acoustic, build calluses fast, and never look back. If you have small hands or any hand-strength concerns, an electric — or a smaller-bodied acoustic — is worth trying in person.
Sound and the music you want to play
Let the music decide. Ask yourself which songs made you want to learn in the first place, then match the instrument:
- Love acoustic-driven artists, folk, or worship? Get an acoustic.
- Dream of riffs, distortion, or guitar solos? Get an electric.
- Not sure and mostly want to strum and sing? An acoustic is the simplest all-rounder.
- Live in a flat with thin walls? An electric with headphones keeps the peace.
Practicality: noise, space, and neighbours
An acoustic is always at speaking volume — lovely for spontaneous playing, less lovely at 11pm in a shared building. An electric is the opposite: unplugged it’s quiet enough to noodle on the sofa, and plugged into an amp with headphones it’s essentially silent to everyone but you. If late-night practice or thin walls are part of your life, that flexibility is a genuine advantage.
Does your choice affect how fast you learn?
Barely. The core skills — open chords, strumming, changing between chords cleanly, reading tab, and keeping time — are identical on both. What determines your progress is consistent practice and a clear plan, not the body shape of your guitar. If you want a step-by-step path from your first chord onwards, follow our beginner guitar roadmap, and if you’re weighing guitar against another instrument entirely, our guitar vs piano comparison is a useful read.
What we’d choose: Whichever body you land on, the fretting hand learns the same way – pairing your new guitar with a structured course like Jamorama means those first weeks go into playing rather than guessing what to practise.
New here? Our Start Here page pulls together the essential first steps in order.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is it harder to learn on an acoustic guitar?
Slightly, in the first few weeks — acoustic strings are under more tension, so your fingertips work harder until you build calluses. The skills themselves are no harder to learn, and most people adjust within a fortnight of regular practice.
Can I learn electric first and switch to acoustic later?
Absolutely, and it works in both directions. Chords, scales, and rhythm transfer straight across. Moving from electric to acoustic just means adjusting to slightly stiffer strings and a bigger body; moving the other way feels like the guitar suddenly got easier.
Do I really need an amp for an electric guitar?
To hear it properly, yes — but a small, inexpensive practice amp is plenty for a beginner. Many starter bundles include one. You can also use a headphone amp or an audio interface into your computer for silent practice.
Which guitar is cheaper overall for a beginner?
Acoustic, usually — because you only buy the guitar. An electric setup adds an amp and cable, though beginner electric bundles keep the total reasonable. Budget for the guitar alone on acoustic, and for the guitar plus an amp and cable on electric — check current prices, as they move about.
What to Read Next
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. If you buy through them we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. We only recommend what we genuinely rate.